Building Materials

Home Improvement Projects ROI Outlook: The 2020 Cost vs. Value Report

Home Improvement Projects ROI Outlook: The 2020 Cost vs. Value Report

According to Remodeling magazine, The 2020 Cost vs. Value report (www.costvsvalue.com) illustrates an unsurprising inclined trend in costs for all the 22 remodeling projects although there is a consistent dip in the perceived value of those home improvement projects at the time of home sale, as projected by real estate professionals in more than 100 metro areas across the United States.

This results in a slight slump on the return on investment for nearly all projects relative to the trends in the previous year’s report.

Though consumers are growing more and more anxious about the U.S. economy, at the very least they can stay certain about the return on investment (ROI) for remodeling.

Cost vs. Value on National Averages

ProjectTrendJob CostValue at SaleCost Recouped
Manufactured Stone VeneerUp$9,357$8,94396%
Garage Door ReplacementDown$3,695$3,49194%
Minor Kitchen RemodelDown$23,452$18,20678%
Siding Replacement (Fiber Cement)New$17,008$13,19578%
Siding Replacement (Vinyl)Down$14,359$10,73175%
Window Replacement (Vinyl)Down$17,461$12,76172%
Deck Addition (Wood)Down$14,360$10,35572%
Window Replacement (Wood)Down$21,495$14,80469%
Entry Door Replacement (Steel)Down$1,881$1,29469%
Deck Addition (Composite)Down$19,856$13,25767%
Roofing Replacement (Asphalt Shingles)Down$24,700$16,28766%
Bathroom Remodel MidrangeDown$21,377$13,68864%
Universal Design BathroomDown$34,643$21,46362%
Roofing Replacement (Metal)-$40,318$24,68261%
Major Kitchen Remodel MidrangeDown$68,490$40,12759%
Master Suite Addition Midrange-$136,739$80,02959%
Bathroom Remodel UpscaleDown$67,106$37,99557%
Bathroom Addition UpscaleDown$91,287$49,96155%
Bathroom Addition MidrangeDown$49,598$26,80754%
Major Kitchen Remodel UpscaleDown$135,547$72,99354%
Grand Entrance (Fiberglass)Down$9,254$4,93053%
Master Suite Addition UpscaleUp$282,062$145,48652%

The table above is sorted by the highest return on investment which ranks all 22 projects in the Cost vs. Value report.

“Trend” shows the change in percentage of cost recouped at the time of home sale compared with the 2019 report.

Cost vs Value by Regional United States

Percentage of costs recouped on re-modeling projects for each region of the country.

ProjectsMiddle AtlanticNew England AreaSouth AtlanticEast-North CentralWest-North CentralEast-South CentralWest-South CentralMountainPacific
Bathroom Addition (Midrange Project)51.0%
51.1%
53.9%
50.8%
50.3%
58.4%
60.5%
52.1%
58.9%
Bathroom Addition (Upscale Project)52.3%
53.3%
54.0%
55.3%
50.0%
46.7%
63.3%
54.1%
66.4%
Bathroom Remodel (Midrange Project)62.5%
63.2%
66.7%
63.8%
52.5%
56.0%
65.7%
62.7%
65.0%
Bathroom Remodel (Upscale Project)56.2%
58.2%
58.6%

57.1%
46.1%
48.6%
61.3%
57.8%
54.0%
Universal Design Bathroom61.4%
66.0%
61.2%
61.1%
53.3%
53.1%
61.8%
60.7%
66.4%
Minor Kitchen Remodel (Midrange Project)79.7%
74.2%
76.3%
69.9%
73.9%
77.6%
76.4%
79.4%
86.6%
Major Kitchen Remodel (Midrange Project)56.3%
55.6%
58.7%
56.7%
52.7%
58.0%
61.3%
58.1%
63.5%
Major Kitchen Remodel (Upscale Project)52.3%
54.1%
53.6%
54.3%
49.5%
50.9%
54.9%
51.2%
57.4%
Master Suite Addition (Midrange Project)52.9%
57.1%
59.1%
55.7%
46.2%
43.1%
61.7%
56.9%
65.2%
Master Suite Addition (Upscale Project)52.9%
48.7%
52.3%
50.5%
41.1%
40.0%
54.8%
50.8%
55.0%
Deck Addition (Composite)73.6%
72.4%
66.6%
64.6%
44.3%
65.6%
57.7%
66.7%
70.6%
Deck Addition (Wood)77.4%
67.5%
77.0%
66.6%
49.0%
81.0%
65.7%
70.1%
77.1%
Entry Door Replacement (Steel)71.4%59.2%
67.0%
63.7%
59.0%
77.2%
72.8%
546.0%
87.9%
Grand Entrance (Fiberglass)56.0%
51.0%
52.7%
51.2%

43.9%
52.1%
53.4%
48.4%
61.1%
Garage Door Replacement106.3%
99.5%
88.7%
79.1%
58.3%
132.7%
73.3%
96.1%
117.1%
Manufactured Stone Veneer89.8%
57.8%
94.0%
66.0%
60.7%
92.1%
91.1%
100.0%
119.5%
Siding Replacement Giber Cement]95.5%
73.9%
90.8%
71.0%
56.1%
99.1%
77.1%
78.6%
78.0%
Siding Replacement (Vinyl)76.2%
76.6%
76.0%
69.3%
56.9%
120.9%
70.4%
74.4%
74.9%
Roofing Replacement (Asphalt Shingles)64.8%
65.8%
68.2%
61.2%
45.0%
57.0%
65.4%
61.6%
75.3%
Roof Replacement (Metal)57.3%
63.3%
65.3%
58.4%
43.1%
52.8%
58.5%
61.1%
65.4%
Window Replacement (Wood)72.1%
75.4%
66.1%
67.1%
48.6%
82.1%
63.7%
69.8%
72.9%
Window Replacement (Vinyl)75.1%
72.6%
73.2%
70.1%
53.4%
84.2%
64.1%
76.5%
74.5%

The power of Cost vs. Value is its regional specificity (which is even more detailed at the metro level).

The above table offers an overview of the regional distinction, which is occasionally dramatic, in the percentage of costs recouped for 22 remodeling projects.

More in Building Materials

7 Creative Indoor and Outdoor Decking Design Ideas

8 Beautiful Color Combinations for your Kitchen Interior Design

Easy Ways for Better Front and Back Yard Landscaping Design